"Apply thine heart unto instruction, and thine ears to the words of knowledge."
(Proverbs 23:12)

 
Search reformedwitness.org Search WWW

 

THE PLACE OF WOMEN IN THE CHURCH by  Prof. Robert D. Decker
 

 From where has the problem of the place of women in the church arisen?  That this is a problem no
one will deny.  The Synods and General Assemblies of the churches have been very busy with this question
in recent years.  The Theological Journals and church magazines carry many articles both pro and con
though mostly pro and several books have appeared on the subject.  Women are enrolling in increasing
numbers in the seminaries and some churches are ordaining them into the ministry and other offices.  But
the question persists, why?  Why all the controversy over this question?  For many centuries this was never
a problem.  The church simply assumed that the office was limited to men.

 The answer very simply is this:  Compromise!  The church once more has accommodated itself to
the world.  We live in the day of "women's liberation", women's rights, and the feminist movement.  Women
are clamoring for equality and seeking their fulfillment not in the home, not in rearing a family, but in the
professions and jobs of the work-a-day world.  The world says wives are not subject to their own husbands
and need not obey them.  The world says marriage is a fifty-fifty proposition and the world says women
may rule over men.  And much of the church has caved in to the pressures of the world and compromised so
that now all of a sudden we need women officebearers; ministers, elders, and deacons.

 But there is the problem!  The Bible, in plain language which even a child can understand,
expressly forbids women from serving as ministers or rulers in the church.  Careful, believing exposition
will yield no other conclusion.  Thus those who advocate that women be in office in the church are forced to
deny that the Scriptures apply in our times and culture.  They say that when Paul wrote:  "I suffer not a
women to teach, nor to usurp authority over the man but to be in silence."  (I Tim. 2:12) was influenced by
his rabbinical training and background.  Or they say this word applied in that early New Testament day but
it does not apply in our culture.

 Hence another and much more serious concession is made, this time to the modern, liberal denial
of the inspiration and infallibility of the Bible itself.  It is couched in high-sounding theological jargon.  We
are told that the Bible is time bound or culturally conditioned.  We must understand that the Bible speaks to
its times.  It is our tasks today to discover how the Bible applies to our times.  Or, we are told, we must get
at the basic meaning of the words themselves by following the rules and methods of the "new hermeneutic."
All this is simply a denial of the most fundamental tenet of our faith, the inspiration and infallibility of the
Bible.  With these views one can make the Bible say anything, support any heresy, deny any truth.  And this
is precisely what is happening in our day.

 The fact, remains, however, that the Bible expressly forbids women from serving in office in the
church.  This is clear from I Corinthians 14:34, 35:  "Let your women keep silence in the churches:  for it is
not permitted unto them to speak; but they are commanded to be under obedience, as also saith the law.
And if they will learn anything, let them ask their husbands at home:  for it is a shame for women to speak
in the church."  This passage is so utterly simple it hardly needs explanation.  The women must keep silence
in the churches; she is not allowed to speak.  That speaking must be taken in the sense of preaching and
teaching in God's church.  This the woman is not allowed to do.  It is not at all unlikely that among the other
abuses in the Corinthian church the woman was being allowed to participate in the leading of worship.  This
not to be permitted for the woman is commanded by God's law to be under obedience.  Hence, let the
women keep silence in the churches!  Indeed it is a shame for women to speak in the churches, a shame
mind you!

 We find this same truth in I Timothy 2:11, 12:  "Let the woman learn in silence with all subjection.
But I suffer not a woman to teach, not to usurp authority over the man, but to be in silence."  The Apostle is
speaking of the official worship of the church of Jesus Christ.  The Church, its offices, its worship, the
various qualifications for office, the duties of ministers, elders, and deacons, all these are the subjects of this
first Letter to Timothy.  This means the Apostle is not speaking of the woman's place in the home, in
society, but of her calling in the church.  The woman, for example, must teach and rule her children.  The
Word, therefore, "I suffer not a woman to teach" means in the church.  The woman is forbidden to occupy
the pulpit.  She may not be ordained into the office of the ministry of the Word.

 Nor may the woman usurp authority over the man.  The term, "usurp authority" means literally: "to
act on one's own authority, to be autocratic."  Again the Scripture means in the church.  The woman may not
occupy the ruling office of Christ in the church, that of the bishop or elder.  The woman who does is a
usurper!  She acts on her own authority, not on God's.  Rather the woman must learn in silence with all
subjection.  She must learn the truth and grow in the knowledge of God by means of the preaching of the
Word.  She must learn in silence, literally in quietness.  This means a bit more than just not talking.  In
quietness means the woman must tend to her own affairs and in her own God-given place and task she must
learn.  The woman must not meddle into the affairs which God had assigned to the men of the church.  Still
more, she must learn in silence with all subjection.  Subjection is obedience and all subjection is total
obedience.  In this way the woman must learn in silence.

 The reason for this is given in verses 13 and 14.  Adam was first formed then Eve.  This means the
woman was made for the man and not the man for the woman.  And, Adam was not deceived, but the
woman being deceived was in the transgression.  This does not mean that Adam did not fall into sin.  But
Adam was not deceived in the way that the woman was deceived.  The woman was utterly and completely
deceived.  She was the leader in the fall and became the occasion for Adam to fall.  The woman listened to
the devil and talked with him.  As a consequence God said: "Thy desire shall be to thy husband and he shall
rule over thee."  (Genesis 3:16).  Therefore the woman must neither teach nor rule in the church.

 Verse fifteen of this chapter call women to their proper place and task.  And that is childbearing!
"She shall be saved in childbearing."  This needs all the emphasis we can give it in our day!  Childbearing
includes the actual conception and bearing of children and all the rearing of them in God's fear.  God gives
the women of the church ample opportunity to teach and to rule.  They must teach and rule their little ones
in the fear of His Name.

 What a glorious task that is!  What a beautiful place God has given the women of the church!  In
this way God's church is born into the world and gathered.  In this way Christ was born.  He was born of a
woman and God did not need a man.  Can there be anything more wonderful than to be used of God for the
building of His church?  Childbearing!  Unto this end God blesses the woman with many gifts and virtues,
fits her physically and emotionally.  What a heinous sin when women and men with them refuse that calling
and refuse to bear children.  The judgement of God rests upon them.

 Through that childbearing the woman shall be saved!  She hall be saved by the blood of Christ
through faith, but not in the way of preaching and teaching in the church, but in the way of childbearing.
What about women to whom God in His inscrutable wisdom does not give this privilege of bearing
children?  Let them be known for their being full of good works and almsdeeds as Dorcas of old.  Let them
visit the fatherless and widow in their affliction.  Let them assist the poor and be involved in helping in
God's church.  Let them stand in the place of the parent in the Christian School and teach the children of
God's covenant.  But let them not be preachers, elders or deacons in the church.  That the Scriptures do not
allow.

 The conclusion is obvious.  Scripture is perfectly clear.  The woman is not permitted to preach,
rule, or minister the mercies of Christ in God's church.  This is the teaching of  I Timothy 2 and of  I
Corinthians 14.  Either one believes that and walks accordingly or he rejects that.  One thing is sure, one
cannot argue on the basis of these passages that women are permitted to enter the offices in the church.